Goodreads Book Giveaway

MENtal by Deanna Reina

MENtal

by Deanna Reina

Giveaway ends April 12, 2026.

See the giveaway details at Goodreads.

Enter Giveaway

Thank You, but You’re Not Hired: Part 2

If you have not read Thank You, but You’re Not Hired., please do so here before continuing. https://deannareina.com/thank-you-but-youre-not-hired/

The story isn’t necessarily over when it’s over.

After writing this blog post, I decided to send the hiring manager an email to thank him for the inspiration for the blog, which I included in the email.

Soon after sending it, he replied.

Hey Deanna – I cannot express to you how much joy this brought me. As you probably picked up from out conversation, we are incredibly busy over here and it can start to feel very robotic just trying to get things done amongst the chaos. That said, I very much needed to hear this from you as much as you needed to hear that from me. You made my heart very full with your words, And believe it or not, that was the first “rejection” letter I’ve ever sent out. Your positive reinforcement will certainly encourage me to approach the firing process the same way moving forward.

I have much faith you will find your new home soon enough.

A few days later, a recruiter reached out to me to discuss an interim Financial Planning and Analysis opportunity. While he was describing the opportunity, I began to realize that he was talking about the same company I had been rejected from. He was surprised as he thought I was a “slam dunk”. I further explained that it was the best rejection I had ever received and I blogged about it. I shared the post with the recruiter.

He replied.

Deanna – thanks for sharing. I appreciate turning a not-so-great situation into a positive mentality. And I agree, you’ll make an impact elsewhere sooner rather than later. I hope I can be a part of that success for you! Let’s stay in touch. Best of luck! 

I thanked him and asked if he had been in touch with his contact. The recruiter said he had been in touch and based on that conversation, he didn’t seem to think that the opportunity was moving forward.

So I went on with my life. I continued to look for jobs, work on my real estate business, think about other areas I wanted to pursue, work on personal projects and goals, hang out with friends and family, salsa dance, and just enjoy my life.

A couple of weeks later, I was curious as to the status of the role, so I sent another email to the hiring manager asking if he had hired someone because I had been contacted by a recruiter about an interim role there. I also offered to work on an interim basis if he needed the help. He replied to me that they decided to hold off on the role and were trying to explore other options including interim help. He also asked if the recruiter was internal or external and I explained that it was external.

A few days later, the hiring manager asked to speak with me. In that conversation he told me that he didn’t know I was open to interim and that they were looking for help. He told me he was going to present my background and figure out how they were going to structure an opportunity.

Today, I received a call from that same recruiter offering me an interim role at the company I was “rejected” from.

So there you have it. Connection, Positivity, Creativity, Karma, Perseverance, and Fate all come together. And the opportunity to add two stories to this blogger’s belt!

What can you do to steer your path? Please share your thoughts here!

Thank You, but You’re Not Hired.

Here I go, dreaming about the swashbuckling life I could lead while I am in between jobs. At times, I am weighed down with moments of fear of the unknown. I wonder where my next paycheck is coming from?

I job search on job boards like www.linkedin.com or www.indeed.com and drop my resume into the abyss of resumes of thousands of other job seekers, wondering what the fate of that attached file will be. Will someone’s eyeballs actually skim my resume or will I just not have the right keywords to be picked up by some resume software? Was there already an internal candidate down selected and for compliance purposes, the company just needed to open the position up to the public? Who knows. All I know is the all too familiar rejection letter that states, “thank you, but we will not be moving forward”. You’ve been rejected, and you feel dejected. I’m no stranger to this world. I’ve been here many times, so the moments aren’t as worrisome as they were in the past, but I am human.

I awoke from a dream, actually a nightmare, that I was interviewing for a job at a company I formerly worked for. It’s the second time I dreamt that I was interviewing there. I grabbed my phone to check what new emails had arrived while I was asleep, and there it was — an email from the hiring manager of a company I had had a third interview with. I started to read it and the words actualized my bad feeling. I didn’t get the job.

Except this was different. The hiring manager actually wrote the note as opposed to receiving a canned message from HR or worse yet, no response at all. It read as follows.

Really appreciate your time last week and your patience as we worked through the process on our end. We very much enjoyed the conversation and certainly believe you have a qualifying background for the role, but we will be moving forward with another candidate who we believe betters aligns from an industry perspective (which is very niche). 

If nothing else, we received around 300 applications last time I checked, and we narrowed it down to around 5 (you being one of them)…so certainly just an extremely refined applicant pool.

Best of luck in your search and praying for much success in your next endeavor.

It was the best rejection letter I’d ever received! In fact, at the time of the interview with the hiring manager, he had told me that they had about 250 applicants, so it was already nice to know that I was plucked out of a pile of that size. My confidence was already boosted! And now to learn that I was the top five out of 300, well, I didn’t have that deflated feeling. I felt proud to have made it that far. I remember what has always happened before. You can’t keep my down. I always come back and better. So look beyond that rejection sign and see the beautiful blue sky with pillowy clouds — opportunities — that lie ahead.

With that, I will look forward to the next opportunity. Whatever you are, you will be lucky to have me.

Please share your thoughts here!